Best Insurance for Seniors Driving Under 5,000 Miles Nationwide, Root, and USAA are our top picks for auto insurance for seniors who drive much less than average. There are specialist car insurance policies for over 50s and older drivers. Read Which?'s expert reviews to find the best over 50s car insurance. Which are the best car insurance companies for seniors? The company you choose can also affect your rates. The average annual premium for car insurance for a 70-year-old driver is $2,410, but shopping around can make a big difference. To identify the best car insurance for seniors, we analyzed 140,000 senior car insurance rates, evaluated 148,000 consumer opinions to gauge customer satisfaction, and researched coverage options. Find the best auto insurance for seniors in New York with The Hartford. Rates start at $43/month. Read now to compare NY insurance companies for seniors. Shopping around, asking about discounts and avoiding accidents can help seniors pay lower auto insurance rates. Compare the best and cheapest car insurance for senior drivers. See average rates by age, top discounts, and quotes from 120+ companies on Insurify. Compare the best car insurance for seniors in year. Discover top-rated providers offering low-mileage discounts, telematics, and exclusive AARP benefits. The best auto insurance for seniors features affordable rates and good customer support. See WalletHub's picks for the best auto insurance for seniors. What is the best auto insurance for seniors that don t drive much? Allstate, American Family, Nationwide and USAA have the best car insurance for seniors who don't drive much. All four offer pay-per-mile insurance, which can save you money if you only drive occasionally. How do I insure a car I barely drive? Low-mileage drivers may save money with discounts, pay-per-mile policies, or usage-based insurance. The best way to see if you can save on your premium is to get quotes from multiple.